During Pittsburgh Penguins General Manager Kyle Dubas' press conference announcing that the team and long-time head coach Mike Sullivan were parting ways on April 29, he had this message:
“You can use whatever analogy you want. Sometimes, the class needs a new professor and sometimes the professor needs a new class... That was the conclusion that I had come to,” he said.
Penn State Athletic Director Pat Kraft had a similar situation to consider before announcing the decision Sunday following another devastating loss, this time to Northwestern on Homecoming at West Shore Home Field at Beaver Stadium.
“Penn State owes an enormous amount of gratitude to Coach Franklin who rebuilt our football program into a national power,” he said. “He won a Big Ten Championship, led us to seven New Year’s Six bowl games and a College Football Playoff appearance last year. However, we hold our athletics programs to the highest of standards, and we believe this is the right moment for new leadership at the helm of our football program to advance us toward Big Ten and national championships.”
Penn State President Neeli Bendapudi shared a similar reaction in the same press release.
“I am grateful for all that Coach Franklin has done for Penn State football and the University over the past 11-plus years. We thank him for his dedication, and we extend our best wishes to him and his family as they move forward into their next chapter,” she said. “Our commitment to excellence extends across every facet of our institution, including athletics, and I am looking forward with great anticipation to this exciting new chapter for the Nittany Lions as we continue to build on that standard."
Sunday, Penn State came to the conclusion that many programs have had to consider before them: A coach can be good coach, but no longer the right coach.
After dropping back-to-back games where the Nittany Lions were 20+ point favorites (the first to do that since the FBS and FCS split in 1978) to teams that on paper that they should've beaten soundly, Franklin is now out of a job.
But even as this era comes to a heartbreaking end as hopes of a Big Ten and national championship have faded for 2025, Nittany Nation should be looking back upon his era with great pride once the dust settles.
Yes, he will have an awful record of 4-21 against teams ranked in the top 10, but there's so much more that Franklin had to manage to put Penn State back in the discussion for being national championship and Big Ten contenders.
Think back to where the program was when you woke up the morning of January 11, 2014 when Franklin was introduced by then Athletic Director Dr. David Joyner.
It was a program that was picking up the pieces after the NCAA's harsh sanctions, was expecting to be serving the third year of a bowl ban, but was allowed to start restoring scholarship allotment as the punishment was lightened.
Eight months later the bowl ban was lifted, and two years later the Nittany Lions took off on their unexpected Big Ten Conference Championship run in 2016, sparked by Marcus Allen's field goal block before Grant Haley took it to the house sending Beaver Stadium into a frenzy against Ohio State.
During Franklin's tenure Penn State registered six 10-plus win seasons -- including the last three which is the first time program has accomplished that since 1980-1982.
Along with an appearance in seven New Year's Six Bowl games (a 4-3 record) along with making the 2024 College Football Playoff Semifinals, Franklin has left Penn State in a position far greater than what he inherited from his predecessor, Bill O'Brien.
His era is the most successful football Penn State has enjoyed since Joe Paterno was in his prime from the late 1970s to the mid 1980s, and Nittany Nation has plenty to be thankful for from that.
There will be plenty of what ifs from this era of Penn State Football, looking back at missed opportunities in big games among others.
But, Penn State should look back on this time with happy memories because at a time when the Nittany Lions were expected to be down for sometime, they found away to bring the program back to prominence rather quickly.
Bill O'Brien deserves a lot of the credit for keeping the program afloat during the 2012 and 2013 seasons, but James Franklin deserves much of the credit for taking what O'Brien built and turning it into what the program has become.
Unfortunately, this decision comes at a difficult financial time as Penn State's $700 million renovation continues at Beaver Stadium while having to pay out close to $50 million in a buyout while having to add another $100-$150 million depending on final negotiations.
Penn State will now get to do something it hasn't done since the Nittany Lions promoted Joe Paterno to the head coach position in 1966 after he succeeded Rip Engle (who Franklin is tied for second-most wins in program history): hiring a coach without the scandal hanging over their heads.
Kraft understands how important it is to get this hiring right as now this will be the first time Penn State will make this kind of hiring in the NIL era. Franklin should also get looks elsewhere if he desires to continue coaching especially from programs who need help taking the next step toward relevance.
But no matter where the future takes either of them, once the dust settles, Penn State fans should look back on this era with a lot of pride.
